Gaming's AI refusniks demand purity

Despite being indie royalty, House House's latest game has been booted out of the IGF awards.

Share
Gaming's AI refusniks demand purity

About ten lines of code fixed a shadow-caster problem in Unity's render pipeline, and were heavily rewritten before they shipped. That is the entirety of the generative AI in Big Walk, and it has cost developer House House its standing at the only awards show that matters to studios like it.

The sequence is worth setting out with care, because it says so much about how gaming's self-selected elite are struggling with this new technology.

On 9th November, Aftermath reported that 19 jurors for the 2027 Independent Games Festival had signed a statement saying "this year we are declining to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any capacity."

It cited "a significant increase in the number of submitted games developed with generative AI tools." On code specifically, it was unambiguous.

"AI-generated code is not an exception to these harms. Programming is a creative discipline whose labor deserves the same respect we extend to any part of making a game."

The signatories noted they "do not speak for IGF as an organization, or for all IGF jury members," but they urged the festival "to adopt a strong anti-AI policy for future years that disallows games containing any AI-generated work."

But Aftermath reported some jurors who shared these concerns did not sign, over worries about professional blowback.

Within hours, House House added an AI section to the FAQ of its game Big Walk. LLMs "were used sparingly by House House to help work through difficult technical challenges and bugs" it said.

Snippets were sometimes taken as a starting point and modified into game code. Well under 0.1% of the game's code had anything to do with it. "Generative AI was not used in any other context when making the game." The worked example is the Unity shadow-caster fix, arrived at after the problem could not be solved manually or through the engine's own support.

Then came the detail that makes this as much a governance story as an AI story. The studio says it wrote that disclosure because it was a suggested part of its IGF submission. It made no disclosure on Steam because "the platform does not request disclosure of code or chatbot usage." The only reason the statement is public is that "we are posting this disclosure as it has become a matter of public interest."

So House House told the IGF, voluntarily, in the one venue that asked. The IGF keeps submission disclosures internal. Jurors then publicly committed to a line that the disclosure crossed. The game lost contention with no hearing, no published rule and no notification anybody can point to, and the studio only spoke out because the connection leaked. Every participant behaved correctly and the outcome is a studio defending itself in a website FAQ against a charge nobody formally made against it.

The storefront half of that is the part worth focusing on too, because Steam's silence is not an oversight. Valve's disclosure form covers AI in the shipped product and in its marketing, and since a revision on 16th January developers "do not need to disclose if they used ‘AI powered tools’ (like code helper software) used for workflow purposes."

A coding assistant is the example the policy itself reaches for. That is a defensible line, but its consequence here is a studio that correctly did not disclose on the platform that distributes its game, was then judged on the same fact by a body that had asked. One institution told them it was none of its business. The other treated it as disqualifying. Both were applying their own stated policy.

Which produces the structural problem underpinning this. Nothing would have caught Big Walk. Steam does not ask about code. No audit exists that could establish whether a studio consulted a chatbot about a shader two years ago. A line drawn at "any capacity" is unverifiable by construction, which means it can only ever be enforced against studios that volunteer the information. House House is in this position precisely and exclusively because it answered a question honestly.

That is not a deduction, and the evidence for it predates this case by six weeks. Morgan Ramsay, who says on his own site that he has volunteered as an IGF judge since 2014, posted this on 26th September: "If you make indie games and want a fair shot at awards, do not disclose any use of AI. I’ve seen judges nominate games only to reverse course after reading the disclosure." A judge of long standing, describing nominations withdrawn once a disclosure had been read, and concluding that the rational advice to a developer is silence. He wrote it before anyone outside the jury pool had heard of Big Walk’s submission. Big Walk is what happens to a studio that does the opposite.

As for the jurors' argument, many people will consider it pedantic to the point of ensuring indie games become a navel onto which only the pure in heart are allowed to gaze.

But, despite their absolutism, their argument is coherent. Their case is that programming is creative labor, and that the harm sits in the training data taken without consent — "the past work used to train these models without the creators' consent," as the statement puts it.

If that is the objection, volume is irrelevant. Ten lines and ten thousand come out of a model built the same way, so "well under 0.1%" is not a mitigation, it is a measurement of something the argument does not care about.

But it is also a stance that, applied evenly, disqualifies most of the industry, and will in practice only ever be applied to the fraction who are honest, which will now be a sharply falling fraction.

As an aside, it's also worth noting that House House is a studio with impeccable credentials in the culture wars. It declined to release Big Walk on Xbox, in line with the Palestinian-led BDS campaign's designation of Microsoft as a boycott target. The game shipped on Steam, PlayStation 5 and Switch 2 instead.

This is a studio that has already given up a platform's worth of revenue on principle. It is not a studio looking for the cheap route out, and it is a strange one to have become the test case.

But that's what happens when Saturn gets fearful. He eats his children, even his favorites.