When it talks AI, Pearl Abyss has two audiences
Investors want to hear how Pearl Abyss uses AI to make games faster and cheaper. Players want as little AI as possible.
Every listed games company now has to describe its use of AI to two audiences who want opposite answers.
Investors want to know how the technology is making the business faster, cheaper and more productive. Players want to see as little of it as possible. Pearl Abyss, the Korean developer of Black Desert and Crimson Desert, has spent this year answering both, and its public documents show how far apart the two answers can drift without either one being untrue.
Start with the players. On 23rd March, three days after they found AI-generated paintings hanging in Crimson Desert, the studio apologized. It said the team had used "experimental AI generative tools" to make some "2D visual props" early in production, and that some had reached the launch build by mistake.
"This is not in line with our internal standards, and we take full responsibility for it," the statement said. "We also acknowledge that we should have clearly disclosed our use of AI."
The studio promised a comprehensive audit of the game's assets, replacements in later patches and a review of its internal processes. The Steam AI disclosure that had been missing at launch was added afterward, and at least one player asked Valve for a refund on the strength of it.
The notice now on the Steam page for Crimson Desert Enhanced, repeated word for word on the Charting the Unknown DLC released on 30th October, reads: "Generative AI technology is used in a supplementary capacity during the creation of some 2D prop assets. Any such assets are replaced through our production pipeline by our art and development teams, ensuring they meet our quality standards and creative direction." That is the account players get. Generative AI touched some 2D props, and people replaced them.
Investors get a different account, however, and a fuller one. Pearl Abyss's second-quarter earnings letter, published on 11th August, says AI "is applied across various stages of development — including the automation of repetitive tasks, content creation support, and QA testing efficiency," and that the company is "expanding its scope across our entire pipeline."
The third-quarter letter on 12th November repeats that almost word for word, and adds detail on DokeV, its next major game, targeted for the second half of 2028.
"While we previously validated game systems only after implementing them manually, we now utilize AI to rapidly validate diverse design concepts prior to actual implementation," it says, which "enables a more efficient allocation of development resources and enhances overall production speed."
That is the language shareholders want: speed, efficiency and resource allocation. It sits in the same letter as a headcount of 996, down 3.8% on the quarter, and a commitment to "hire only essential positions in 2026, maintaining a conservative approach to overall hiring." The company draws no link between the two, but an investor reading the letter can read between the lines.
Indeed, the investor presentation goes further. On page 17 of the deck published alongside the November results, under "Company Strength: Development," the proprietary BlackSpace Engine is presented as an "AI-based Game Engine," and its listed advantages include "AI-based automated coding" and "Convenient programming (Automated development)."
That slide is not new. It appears in the decks from May 2025, November 2025 and August 2026, and in the March 2026 deck, which went up on 25th March, two days after the apology.
The company timeline in the same deck dates its "New AI-based engine" to 2019, in the same entry that records the introduction of Crimson Desert. From August, the deck also carries a ten-year strategy slide with the line: "As technology transforms the way we produce, human time moves towards deeper experiences."
For investors, AI is presented as a competitive strength, with a seven-year history and a growing role. For players, it is a supplementary tool that touched some props, which were then replaced, or accidentally not. Both accounts were published in the same week in March and have been running side by side since.
What lets them coexist is Steam's rule. Valve's disclosure form asks developers about AI-generated content that ships in the game or its marketing, and since a revision on 16th January developers "do not need to disclose if they used 'AI powered tools' (like code helper software) used for workflow purposes."
The rule is about what ends up in front of the player, not how the game was made. Generated paintings left in a shipped build fall inside it. Automated coding, AI-assisted testing and design validation, which is everything Pearl Abyss tells its investors about, fall outside it.
So the Steam notice covers the 2D props because that is what Steam asks about, and the earnings letters cover the pipeline because that is what shareholders ask about. Nothing the company tells investors is required on its store page.
The strain shows in the one place where a single document tries to serve both. The November letter follows its DokeV passage with a sentence that reads as though it were written for players:
"However, AI serves strictly as a tool to support concept validation and pipeline productivity, while the core gameplay experience and actual content creation remain fully driven by our development team." Eleven pages later, the same letter lists "content creation support" among the things AI is used for. The company is telling shareholders that AI runs through its whole pipeline while reassuring players that it doesn't touch anything they would see, and the two halves of the message meet uncomfortably in the middle.
But Pearl Abyss is not hiding anything. The fullest public account of how it makes games has been on an investor slide since at least May 2025. It is simply not where players look, and nothing requires it to be.
- Players object to AI in games broadly, but the only rule that speaks for them covers the output narrowly.
- Investors want to hear about AI broadly, and the documents written for them get broader every quarter.
As long as that holds, every publisher in Pearl Abyss's position will give two accounts, and both will be accurate. As for the comprehensive audit promised in March, no account of its findings has been published.